Tuesday, May 6, 2014

Creativity and Agency

I have observed a trend for Christians to have an odd view of creativity, especially whenever it relates to creating something “good.” The phrase “God gave me a [insert creative endeavor here]” is thrown around lot. The heart behind this is good and genuine; God is the Author and Creator, the only Independent One. At the end of the day I am creature, and I am creative solely because I have been made to be creative. We have been created to create; it’s a part of being made in His (the Creator’s) image.  It is good for us to guard against pride and make sure to give God credit, but we can take this logic too far and inadvertently deny God some of the glory He is due.

If God gave me the “cool idea” I had, the poem I wrote, this blog post, did He give me the burrito I made for lunch? Technically the answer is ‘yes.’ Without getting into the details like: money, time, mind, food, we have the fundamental truth that I exist, the world exists, I have hands for folding burritos, and the very concept of burritos all because of God. No God, no burritos. It’s a perk of being Independent; everything else depends upon you.

The reason phrases like “God gave me a …” make me nervous is that it seems to deny any involvement on our part. “I did not write this worship song, God gave it to me” begins to sound
less like cooperative creativity and more like possession; I did not have anything to do with it, God just gave it to me. In truth God does not want worship songs, sermons, paintings, etc. apart from the people who have created them. If God wanted a song to exist He does not need anyone else; He imagined light, He can make a song manifest all by Himself. Rather than using us as some sort of printing press for His awesome ideas, God wants to create with us and through us. God did not need David to have psalms written; God delighted in His relationship with David. Please do not misunderstand this as some denial of the Divine authorship of Scripture, it’s not. God does not love and have a personal relationship with Psalm 119, but He does with David.

The term “agency” used in stories to describe characters who have the ability to effect the plot, and important characters usually have significantly more agency than random extra #8. God, being independent, is the source of all agency. He is also a good storyteller which means He has created us to be more than mere puppets He can manipulate as He sees fit. Relationship with God is not fatalistic or mechanistic; instead God in His goodness has granted me some agency on the world around me. I can create things. For His glory.

Furthermore any demeaning of human creativity denies God some of His glory. Our ability to be creative, to have agency, is one of God’s most glorious creations. We as humans have made a lot of things, we have created machines which would appear to be very fatalistic if one considers the point of view of a toaster; but we have not made something which can itself create. But God has.  He alone has, which makes Him pretty awesome and worthy of a lot of glory.


So let us glorify our awesome and Independent Creator by reflecting His creativity with our own.